I've been listening to all the uproar on talk radio about the word 'scrotum' which appears in the book “The Higher Power of Lucky,” by
Susan Patron, this year’s winner of the Newbery Medal, the most
prestigious award in children’s literature. 10-year-old orphan Lucky Trimble, hears the word through
a hole in a wall as she listens in as someone describes how a rattlesnake bit
his dog, Roy, on the scrotum.
Aside from the fact that no-one who owns a dog uses that word - we're all more likely to say 'look at that huge great Rottweiler, jeez why does he still have his balls? Hey mister, get your dog fixed.' At which point, the owner - a small man, wearing baggy pants, puts his hands uncomfortably into his pockets and tells you to mind your own damn business, and feels around for that reassurance that yes, indeed, he, like his whopping dog is still a man, still intacta non grata. Scrotum? I don't think so.
So, you kind of wonder - why did the author feel the need to introduce a word not in common use at all, to describe a situation that would more likely have been described thus - 'man, the worst thing happened, totally spooky, my dog Roy, you know, the one that jumped that spaniel last week, he was trolling around in a dirtpile and some rattler just up and bites him on the balls, right in the crotch, no shit.'
No ifs, ands, butts or scrotums. I'm just a bit mystified. But school librarians across the nation have gone on a rampage, banning the book, refusing to order it, expressing fear and terror, not to mention loathing of this 'dirty' word.
Me? I'm just totally bummed that a good author doesn't use her bully pulpit in a children's book to promote spay and neuter. It would have been just as painful had she written that Roy had been bitten on his haunches, on his penile shaft, on his shrunken testicles, no? You all know I'm kidding right? I have been accused of too much dry wit, and irony and as Americans don't do irony, I feel as if I have to explain myself more.
But let's talk body parts for a moment. This is reminding me of a story by Lisa Palac in her autobiographical 'The Edge Of The Bed: How Dirty Pictures Changed My Life' in which she which refers to me as 'a butch dyke in a black leather jacket and an english accent' getting all worked up because Susie Bright (my friend and former housemate) and Lisa had let my cats out of our apartment in San Francisco while they romped naked in Susie's bedroom with Nina Hartley's G string. This is, of course, a completely true story and one which you should check out in the book. The day after, as Lisa and Susie prepared to get their labia(s) pierced, I, who have the worst phobia of needles in anyone over 5 years of age, loaded my camera, checked that my flash unit was working (because after all, a needle sliding through a labia is not something that you can do a second take on), and readied myself to throw up - if the blood, the screams or the sight of it just made me lose it. I didn't eat breakfast that day.
I have to say, it hurt me more than it hurt either of them. I have been scarred for life by that experience, and can't even be in a room when a vaccine is given to a dog these days, scrotum-less or not.
But, back to the story. Lisa writes that the next day, I casually asked 'So, how's your cunt?'. And she notes that this was the first time she had ever heard the word 'cunt' used without embarrasment, or as an attack.
And that is the point of this - when we continue to allow words that describe sex, our genitalia, or our identities (be they the clinical text book words or common slang) to conjure up disdain, hate, fear and mystery in chldren's minds, we continue to perpetuate the worst forms of self oppression and self condemnation.
So, I'm a bit contrary here - Susan Patron, you shoulda just have written 'Roy, whose balls were nipped by a rattler, was damn sore for weeks afterwards. He was lucky to be alive, and his owner decided that it was way past time to get him castrated. Roy, for his part, looked over at his owner/guardian and said 'It's ok dude, they're my balls, not yours.'
Now there's a kids story that everyone can believe in.
Recent Comments